Shannon Swingley Noir, Film and Novel Professor Sinowitz December 15, 2017. 1300 The Watchmen as a Neo-Noir Watchmen is a superhero film adapted by Zack Snyder based on the DC comics written in the 1980’s. The Watchmen, made up of the Comedian, Ozymandius, Dr. Manhattan, Nite Owl II, Rorschach, and Silk Spectre II, are a band of masked hero’s modeled after the minutemen of their parent’s generation. All of the minutemen are lost to time except for the Comedian, and the Watchmen are left to look after the wellbeing of the world, despite their success in helping the west win the Vietnam war and keep Nixon in the Whitehouse, the multiterm president outlaws masked heroes, disbanding the team. The Comedian and Dr. Manhattan are coerced to work with the government. The doctor keeping an eye on nuclear dangers in the world, and despite his efforts soviet posturing for nuclear attack during the cold war is coming to a head. Ozymandius, now Adrian Veidt capitalizes on his identity as...
I loved your play! It was so cute and interesting! I could picture it ALL in my head and it was super entertaining. Anyway, the analysis part at the end was good but I felt like it was a tad underdone. It was interesting to read about Beth and how she deserved more and couldn't escape her archetype. It reminded me of our class discussions about Out of the Past (how Jeff couldn't stop going back to his life of crime) and Laura (who is very much a two dimensional character). What's the motive besides Beth deserves more? Why should we as the audience, focus on her and care? What is noteworthy about the repeating cycles besides the feeling of doom throughout the book? Overall, really liked the creativity that was here and the obvious wok you put into this.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was very creative of you to write a play to show your thought process. At the beginning I wasn't sure of the purpose of your play, but I like how at the end of it you analyze Beth's role in the novel. However, as the format of the assignment is a play, I thought it wasn't as deep/insightful as an essay could have been. I thought you could have gone more in depth about why you wanted to write about Beth. Also, when the author says that she is just a character, it seems to go against your argument and makes it seem pointless, as it gives the impression that you are over analyzing something way too much when even the author didn't really think much about it
ReplyDelete